What is crowdfunding for real estate? Everyone has heard about GoFundMe. Most of us understand that people go online to raise money for some cause or other, often a charitable or a worthy one. Some people also raise money for business ventures through platforms like GoFundMe, but you might ask, does that work for real estate projects?
Well, it does.
And while there would be no reason not to try launching a real estate development project on GoFundMe, it isn’t what most GoFundMe users would expect to find. Also, more importantly, you would still have to take care of all the other complicated aspects around real estate deals yourself.
There are crowdfunding sites that are designed for specific kinds of niches, like small business ventures, or creative projects such as movies, or charitable causes. and there are crowdfunding sites that specialize in real estate projects.
Management and clever bits
Real estate development projects involve a great deal of management, and all manner of other services including title search, zoning boards, architectural boards, architectural design, general contracting, and many legal services. All of these services incur fees that eat into the investors’ returns.
Real estate crowdfunding sites seek to create value for their investors by two broad strategies.
Firstly, by doing as many of the costly services in-house to ensure that fees charged to investors are kept low.
Secondly, by carefully vetting development projects and packaging and bundling these into different investment vehicles for their investors. In reality, real estate crowdfunding sites are very much in the real estate business and not just marketplaces where buyers and sellers of real estate can meet.
How they differ
Real estate crowdfunding is a vibrant and competitive sub-sector of the real estate industry.
There are various factors that distinguish real estate crowdfunding sites from each other. Some act as pure middlemen providing investors with access to developers while others act more like developers in their own right.
Another distinction is that some real estate crowdfunds loan investor funds to property owners as debt. The income stream is generated when the property owners repay their debt.
Other real estate crowdfunds use their investors’ funds to acquire equity in the real properties and the collection of rent on those properties provides the income to investors. If the fund has equity in the properties, the sale of the properties at the end of the anticipated holding period also provides capital appreciation to the benefit of investors.
The real estate projects themselves can be commercial office buildings, retail developments, multi-family residential projects, industrial projects, even single-family homes, and different crowdfunding sites have strengths in different areas.
The main real estate crowdfunding sites tailor services for investors at different stages of their investing journey.
Note: This article contains affiliate links
Good examples in the US are:
Diversifyfund Growth REIT, minimum investment $500 and no requirements other than being a US resident.
Fundrise Core, minimum investment $1,000 within Core you can choose one of three strategies: i) Income, ii) Growth, iii) Balance of income and growth.
PeerStreet, accepts investors with a minimum account balance of $1,000
RealtyMogul, a minimum investment of $5,000 will allow you to invest in one of their two REITs provided other conditions are met.
More sophisticated investors
At the $500 to $5,000 level, most of these real estate crowdfunding providers give you access to their non-traded REITs. That means you will be participating in a diversified fund that will be invested in many different real estate projects. Sometimes you can choose whether you participate in the income part of the fund or the growth part of the fund or a blend of the two. That is for you to choose whether your objective is an income stream or a larger payout some time, usually three to five years into the future.
On US-based real estate crowdfunding sites, to be allowed to invest directly in individual real estate projects you normally have to go to the next level as an investor. In most cases, this will mean you need to qualify as an Accredited Investor.
The qualification criteria for being an Accredited Investor vary from state to state. It usually means a combination of
- Annual income in excess of $200,000, recent years, the current year and anticipated for the next year,
- Net worth in excess of $1 million – excluding your primary residence,
- Professional expertise that qualifies you as a sophisticated investor can reduce the above requirements
Essentially, if you qualify as an Accredited Investor that gives you direct access to investing in high-risk, unregulated, or less regulated investment products and vehicles. The law considers that you can accept the risks of these more dangerous investments without the protections afforded to us humbler folk,
Individual real estate projects
Of course, this is the fun part.
If you do meet the requirements and are able to find the necessary funds, you can get to tie your money up directly owning a piece of a commercial property. This is the exciting part of the game where you get to browse a catalog of developments with compelling stories and pictures of apartment blocks or condos with pools and palm trees.
While a good story with pretty pictures always makes a good read, what you should really be interested in is the numbers.
So what numbers would you expect to see with a real estate project on a crowdfunding site? You would expect to see convincing evidence of the project costs, the anticipated revenues in terms of rent, and an assessment of risks.
If a developer has already been identified then the costs of the project including contingencies may be known. Then you would also expect to see how the project costs benchmark against comparable projects, preferably for other properties close to the location of the project.
On the revenue side, you would expect to see evidence of the demand from prospective tenants. The rents expected to be charged should be benchmarked against other similar properties in the location. The revenue projections should be realistic and pass the sniff test from all angles. As an example, if the project is anticipating 100% occupancy within the first few months after it is move-in ready, what evidence is there that supports that claim.
Expect to see an assessment of the broader environment of the project. What other risks are there? What factors outside the control of the project could affect it? How resilient would the project be in a general economic downturn? The answers to these questions could lead you to do some of your own research.
This is all part of the due diligence process. You will want to see that the crowdfunding site has done precisely this sort of rigorous assessment. I would not be shy of asking them questions if the information they present seems incomplete, vague, or unsubstantiated.
A typical equity real estate crowdfunding project
We’ve already noted that an equity real estate crowdfunding project involves the crowdfunding site owning all or part of the property. With equity come some advantages and some risks.
Advantages of equity real estate projects
- There is the possibility of higher returns. In the same way that equity shareholders get paid after all other debts are paid, the largest part of the pie is left for them. Assuming that there is a large pie or any pie at all for that matter.
- There are possible tax advantages. As a part-owner you, as an investor may be able to write-off some or all of your share in renovation or capital improvement costs.
- Fees will usually be lower on equity deals.
Disadvantages of equity real estate projects
- The returns on equity deals tend to take longer to materialize. If the goal is to improve the property through capital improvements over the anticipated holding period and sell at the end of that period, then investors will receive the largest part of their returns at the end of the project.
- There will be a higher risk of loss and that loss can be total. In other words, the whole project could go belly up.
Note: This article contains affiliate links
Diversyfund is an example of a real estate crowdfunding platform that does a majority of equity deals. In fact, it is unique in that it acts as the developer for most of its projects.
A typical debt real estate crowdfunding project
In this arrangement, the crowdfunding site provides the funds to the developer in the form of a loan typically repaid in installments with interest. There are advantages and disadvantages to debt-funded projects.
Advantages of debt-funded real estate projects
- You will get paid sooner. As an investor in a debt-funded real estate project, you will likely start receiving repayments from the project much sooner than is the case with equity deals. These kinds of deals typically generate predictable income streams.
- The repayments should carry less risk. As a holder of the debt, you are paid before shareholders i.e. equity holders.
Disadvantages of debt-funded real estate projects
- There is less upside potential. Since the funding to the project is set up as a loan, the returns over the lifetime of the project are known and there is a ceiling on returns.
- The fees are likely to be higher. There will also be fees associated with setting up the loan. Those fees are going to eat into the returns of the project.
- There is default risk. So while the project may be set up with what might look like an ironclad loan arrangement there is always a risk that the project could fail especially if major construction or renovation works are not yet completed.
- Prepayment risk. In some cases, the debtor may choose to pay off the loan before it comes to term. As an investor, this will mean you will receive less income than anticipated. If this happens, investors would typically look to put their money in other projects sooner than otherwise anticipated.
Peerstreet is an example of a crowdfunding site that does only debt-funded real estate projects.
How to choose a real estate crowdfunding site
So, assuming that you have got as far as deciding that you would like to add real estate investments to your portfolio through a crowdfunding site, how do you choose a crowdfunding site? Here are some criteria I would suggest you consider.
The owners, what is their track record? You will want to see that the founders and owners are real people who have long successful track records in the real estate business.
Years in operation. How many years has the company been in operation? This is a comparatively new industry so many of these operations have only been around for a few years. But obviously the longer they have been around and the more consistent their track record the better sense you would have that this record is likely to continue into the immediate future.
Kinds of projects. What kinds of projects do they have on their books? Do they focus on any particular kind of property, are they focused in specific geographic regions. Do they do only or mainly debt deals or equity deals?
Completed projects. What is their track record of completed projects, what returns were achieved? If they publish information that groups previous projects according to their investment vehicles, that can give you a good sense of the risk profile of those investment vehicles. Fundrise is a good example of this.
Fees. How do their fees compare with other companies? When you get down to your final short-list you should compare the fees they charge.
Financial stability. Is the company financially stable and how do they compare with the competition. This is a hard question to answer because most of these companies are privately owned so there are no financial statements you can look up. The only figures you are likely to be sure of getting are the total value of assets under management, total sums invested with them, disbursements made to investors. One indication would be that they have a spread of projects at different stages on their anticipated timelines. As a general guide the larger they are the more resilient they are likely to be in an economic downturn.
Transparent information. How transparent are they about their projects – do they let you see inspection reports, zoning decisions, title documents. You may need to call them up and ask to see more project details to get a good handle on this. It is important though as going forward you want them to know that
Good figures. How compelling are the figures they present projecting project returns? Is every source figure reasonable and justified? You want to see compelling calculations that are neither vague nor superficial at one extreme nor trying to blind you with science at the other.
Actual returns vs anticipated returns. Do they publish project actual returns vs anticipated returns or do they just cherry-pick and share their best results?
Project vetting. How does the vetting process used by the site work? You want to be convinced by their due diligence process. One potentially meaningful statistic is the percentage of projects that make it through the vetting process.
Equity vs debt projects. Are you looking for equity projects and growth or debt projects and income or a blend of both?
Tax. Are there any tax advantages or is that not a consideration.
Project fit. Lastly, are you comfortable with and interested in the kinds of projects that the site has on its books?
After asking all these questions, if you are comfortable with what you see, then this is probably a good fit for you.
Questions and answers
Q. Is real estate crowdfunding a safe investment?
A. There are risks associated with all kinds of investments including real estate crowdfunding. Generally, the returns on real estate investments through crowdfunding are going to be higher than returns on bonds, in the order of 18 to 25 percent annualized returns on real estate equity projects. Occasionally some real estate projects will go south and if you are an investor in an equity deal the whole of your stake in that deal could be gone. For this reason, it will be good to diversify your real estate crowdfunding holidngs.
Q. Can you build wealth with real estate crowdfunding?
A. If you have a long time horizon, with the returns available, compounding returns then you can build wealth through real estate crowdfunding.
Q. How much should I invest in real estate crowdfunding?
A. Depending on your risk appetite and risk tolerance a typical range for a diversified portfolio would be to have between 5 and 15 percent of the total value in real estate.
I hope you found this article interesting and useful. Do leave me a comment, a question, an opinion, or a suggestion and I will reply soonest. And if you are inclined to do me a favor, scroll down a bit and click on one of the social media buttons, and share it with your friends. They may just thank you for it.
Disclaimer: I am not a financial professional. All the information on this website and in this article is for information purposes only and should not be taken as personalized investment advice, good or bad. You should check with your financial advisor before making any investment decisions to ensure they are suitable for you.
Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you click on a link and buy something, I may receive a commission. You will pay no more so please go ahead and feel free to make a purchase. Thank you.